Many consumers shop for new tires by model, size and their budget. Some tire buyers also go by the brand name they know and trust, and then choose the most appropriate model within that brand for their vehicle. There are many ways to go about it.
Car Talk researchers and dedicated tire experts have analyzed the top 10 tire brands in the industry to help make this decision a little easier. Here is what we found.
How do you determine which tire brand is the best, and how to get the best tire deals available now? We took a look at several sources that rate tires, from independent consumer rating agencies to industry rating agencies, publications and government bureaus. Then we conducted our own research involving a nation-wide survey of over 800 mechanics and industry experts.
In addition, Car Talk’s vehicle experts conduct actual road tests of each of these tires on media vehicles. We also do longer-term tests on our daily drivers. During a given year, we test dozens of the most popular tire models.
The list below shows our calculated ratings for the top ten tire brands in the industry.
We also took a look at how tire brands performed in different areas:
Category | Brand | Pricing |
---|
Michelin is a French multinational tire manufacturer, which has been in business since 1889. Michelin is recognized as the second-largest tire manufacturer on the planet, behind the behemoth Bridgestone, and ahead of brands like Goodyear and Continental.
Michelin offers 50 different tire models, from the Golden Wrench winner for Best All Season CrossClimate2 to the Golden Wrench Winner for Best Performance tire, the Pilot Sport 4S. It’s also one of the manufacturers that offers more than one tire specific to winter climates.
Around the world, and with every rating agency we looked at, Michelin has a stellar reputation for building a quality tire. For this reason, Michelin is our Golden Wrench winner for Best Overall Tire Brand.
During tire testing this year, a set of test tires from another brand our team was evaluating arrived with a visible flat spot from the factory and a second tire would not balance properly. Our local retailer/installer is a highly-rated shop with a very experienced owner. We spoke to the owner about the situation, and he said it is not uncommon for his shop to need to pull five tires from the warehouse to get four “perfect ones.” He said, “My advice is to just get the Michelins.”
Types: All-season tires, touring tires, high performance tires, ultra-high performance tires, winter tires, all-terrain tires, mud-terrain tires.
For more in-depth information, read our full Michelin tires review »
Find the best prices on Michelin Tires with Discount Tire, Tire Rack, and SimpleTire.
Continental is a German tire manufacturer which has been in the business for over 150 years. It’s part of a massive multinational conglomerate that provides all manner of subsystems for automotive and transportation applications. Making tires is just one facet of the business.
Continental has a range of 59 different tires available in the United States. In general, it’s concerned with mainstream automotive tire production, so look to Continental for excellent high-performance tires, touring tires and medium-duty truck and SUV tires, and not so much for the extreme mud-terrain and all-terrain models.
Types: All-season tires, touring tires, high performance tires, ultra-high performance tires winter tires.
For more in-depth information, read our full Continental tires review »
Find the best prices on Continental Tires with Discount Tire, Tire Rack, and SimpleTire.
American tire manufacturer Goodyear has been in the business of building tires since the invention of vulcanization. Founded in 1898, it’s one of the top four tire makers in the world today.
Goodyear has a bewildering array of 85 different tires, in everything from ultra-performance tires like the Eagle F1 Supercar, all the way down to the Radial LS, a budget all-season tire for commuter sedans. About half the tires that Goodyear offers are for trucks and SUVs, so there’s plenty of range there, too.
Types: All-season tires, touring tires, high performance tires, ultra-high performance tires, winter tires, all-terrain tires, mud-terrain tires.
For more in-depth information, read our full Goodyear tires review »
Find the best prices on Goodyear Tires with Discount Tire, Tire Rack, and SimpleTire.
Japanese tire manufacturer Bridgestone has been making hoops since 1931. Because of its purchase of Firestone in 1988, and various other acquisitions over the years, Bridgestone Corporation is the largest tire manufacturer in the world.
It maintains the Bridgestone brand, which offers more than 100 different tire models for just about every kind of driver. Its Potenza line is its ultra-high- and high-performance line, but it also provides the Turanza and Ecopia tires for passenger vehicles. It’s also credited with essentially reinventing the approach to winter tires in the 1990s with its Blizzak tire, of which it now offers nine different varieties.
Types: All-season tires, touring tires, high performance tires, ultra-high performance tires, winter tires, all-terrain tires, mud terrain tires.
For more in-depth information, read our full Bridgestone tires review »
Find the best prices on Bridgestone Tires with Discount Tire, Tire Rack, and SimpleTire.
BFGoodrich has been around since 1870, and is one of the oldest tire manufacturers in existence. It’s been part of the Michelin family of brands since 1990, but has maintained a strong presence in the United States ever since.
For its legacy as a household brand, BFGoodrich has really focused on a narrow range of just 21 different tire models. The g-Force ultra-high performance tires, and the All-Terrain T/A K02 and Mud Terrain KM3 tires are its most popular. The Radial T/A is the only other white-letter 14- and 15-inch tire for vintage muscle cars. It has also made a strong showing with its Advantage T/A touring tires, as a replacement for commuter sedans and sports cars.
Types: All-season tires, touring tires, high performance tires, all-terrain tires, mud terrain tires.
For more in-depth information, read our full BFGoodrich tires review »
Find the best prices on BFGoodrich Tires with Discount Tire, Tire Rack, and SimpleTire.
Cooper has been on the scene since 1914, another one of those Akron rubber manufacturers. It went through some fairly dark days, but recently has been on the upswing providing some standout models in a few categories.
Cooper only offers 21 different models, so it can’t compete with the wide range of the big manufacturers, but where it provides products, it performs well. Most notably, it’s Discoverer truck and SUV tire has been a favorite, and muscle car fans still love the Cooper Cobra, which is one of just a few solid white-letter tires available with fat sidewalls in 14- and 15-inch diameters.
Types: All-season tires, touring tires, high performance tires, winter tires, all-terrain tires, mud terrain tires.
For more in-depth information, read our full Cooper tires review »
Find the best prices on Cooper Tires with Discount Tire, Tire Rack, and SimpleTire.
Japanese manufacturer Yokohama has been turning out tires since 1917, and entered the US market in 1969. Since then, it has opened two manufacturing facilities in the US, and has become a household brand by providing tires for a lot of OEM applications.
There are 76 different Yokohama models available for US consumers, mostly centered around the ADVAN line of performance tires, the Avid all-season/touring tires, and the Geolandar truck and SUV lineup. Subaru owners know Yokohama well, since the Geolander has found its way onto many of the brands’ crossovers as the OEM tire. The severe snow duty-rated Yokohama Geolander A/T G015 trail tire is now the OEM choice for the popular Wilderness trims of Subaru SUV models. Yokohama also has several winter tire offerings.
Types: All-season tires, touring tires, high performance tires, ultra-high performance tires, winter tires, all-terrain tires, mud terrain tires and trail tires.
Find the best prices on Yokohama Tires with Discount Tire, Tire Rack, and SimpleTire.
The Milanese tire manufacturer Pirelli has been in business for nearly 150 years, and has exclusively provided tires for major European racing series and events including the Grand Am Rolex Sports Car Series and FIA Formula One.
Pirelli has 63 tire models, and the bulk of its reputation comes from producing ultra-high performance tires for exclusive performance and sport-luxury cars. However, Pirelli is also a noted producer of high-end tires for trucks and SUVs, with the Scorpion line of tires. It also has a formidable line of track tires, as well as a range of winter performance tires. One notable new Pirelli OEM fitment is the Scorpion ATR all-terrain trail tire fitted to the top trim of the Ford Bronco Sport.
Types: All-season tires, touring tires, high performance tires, ultra-high performance tires, winter tires, all-terrain tires.
For more in-depth information, read our full Pirelli tires review »
Find the best prices on Pirelli tires with Discount Tire, Tire Rack, and SimpleTire.
New to our list for 2024 is Falken. This brand is relatively new to America, entering the market in the 1980s as a specialty tire for racing. While we had previously acknowledged Falken as a brand with popular tires in a narrow area of the market, things are changing for this tire brand.
By 2016 Falken had begun manufacturing tires in Buffalo, New York. Slowly but surely, the brand has steadily increased its industry footprint with its ZIEX all-season tire line. Falken is now an OEM tire choice for many brands’ most popular models including Toyota, Nissan, Mazda, Subaru, Jeep, Ram, Ford, and Mitsubishi. One recent notable win for the brand was being chosen as the OEM tire for the all-new 2024 Subaru Crosstrek Sport. We tested the Falken ZIEX ZE 001A A/S all-season touring tires on the newest Subie for a week this summer and found them to be outstanding in a wide range of driving conditions.
In 2020, Falken began offering its first studded winter tire. Today, Falken is making one of the hottest trail and all-terrain tires for crossovers and SUVs. The WildPeak series has become a factory option on the hugely successful Ford Bronco Sport, as well as off-roady trims of the Toyota RAV4 and Mazda CX-50. This is a much-talked-about tire within online vehicle clubs, and many crossover and SUV owners looking for a better off-pavement tire than the standard all-season tires their vehicle came with are switching to the WildPeak series. With its severe snow duty rating, the WildPeak is a viable year-round choice for many drivers who once relied on dedicated winter tires.
Types: All-season tires, touring tires, high performance tires, ultra-high performance tires, winter tires, all-terrain tires, mud-terrain tires, competition tires.
For more in-depth information, read our full Falken tires review »
Find the best prices on Falken Tires with Discount Tire, Tire Rack, and SimpleTire.
Hankook is the youngest tire brand in our list, having launched as the Chosun Tire Company in South Korea in 1941. Hankook -- the native pronunciation of “Korean” -- was rebranded in 1968, and really only began selling tires here in the 1990s.
With that short history, though, Hankook has become a tire-making force to be reckoned with, delivering a slate of 42 different models, broken into the Ventus high performance line, the Optimo and Kinergy all-season and touring tires, and recently, the Dynapro all-terrain and mud-terrain line.
Types: All-season tires, touring tires, high performance tires, ultra-high performance tires, all-terrain tires, mud terrain tires.
For more in-depth information, read our full Hankook tires review »
Find the best prices on Hankook Tires with Discount Tire, Tire Rack, and SimpleTire.
Car Talk's very active online Community has many interesting and thoughtful perspectives on the best tire brands in the industry, based on real life user experience and knowledge. See what they have to say below.
"Michelin does make great tire but at a high price. 2 sets on 2 cars. One set is on my Mustang right now.
I like Kumhos and have had 4 sets on various cars. Good tires at good prices and not on your list.
5 sets of Firestones on various cars.
4 sets of Hankooks, all track capable tires. Very good track tires.
4 sets of Goodyears, one set of BFGoodrich tires."
- Mustangman
"Michelin is my favorite too. Never any serious problems. I wish they’d revert to making 13 inchers though, for my older Corolla."
- GeorgeSanJose1
"I’ve not had a problem with any brand, I research them, it helps: Michelin, Pirelli, Yokohama, Vredestein, Goodyear. I stay away from the no-names."
- texases
"Definitely Michelin. More expensive to purchase but cheaper in the long run because they last so long."
- Hugemoth_144444
"No favorite brand. I research based on my driving needs. For me, primary need is wet traction. Often comes up with a coin flip between Michelin and Continental. This time the truck got Michelins, probably will go with Continentals for the Mustang.
If I still lived in the Southwest, where we had rain once a year my criteria would be different.
Over the years, from the days of bias ply tires to radials, I have had many different brands even, as I recall, tires branded as K-Mart, in the 1970s on my CJ 5."
- Purebred
Read more on the Best Tire Brands in the industry according to the Car Talk Community here.
All of these tire brands were ranked using Car Talk's unique methodology based on over 30 different data points and hands-on expert testing in the field:
Consumer Satisfaction: This is the key finding in any of these rankings. Consumers provided data about what their experience was using tire models within each of these brands. The thing to keep in mind is that a single brand may get strong ratings for one tire model, but fall apart on others. It’s important to look at these ratings and then find the tires within those brands that best meet your needs, then look at ratings for that particular tire model versus its competition.
Industry Professionals: Car Talk researchers performed a nation-wide survey of over 800 mechanics for their opinions on the best tires available on the market today.
Government Reporting: Statistics reported for safety and durability.
Tire Quality and Engineering: These studies looked at how a tire brand’s overall quality and engineering or innovation influenced a consumer’s decision to purchase.
Performance: All of these agencies looked at how tires from these particular brands performed in wet and dry conditions, under heavy braking and cornering, and in winter weather.
One attribute noticeably absent from the rankings is price. Tires are kind of a “you get what you pay for” situation. One thing that we can extrapolate from this data is that tire brands which are at the lowest rung of the price ladder were the brands that performed below the industry average, almost across the board.
Choosing the best tire brand for you is a personal decision which depends entirely on how you drive, where you drive, the vehicle you have and your budget. If you have a Jeep Wrangler and you take it off roading on the trails in the winter, then you need a reliable, durable tire with the strength to endure your travels. If you're kind of an indoor cat, live in a city, work at home and barely use your vehicle, then you'll need an entirely different, less rugged tire. Price, availability, longevity and treadlife all come into play.
Ratings and consumer reviews are a great place to start. Doing the research to decide which type of tire fits your needs, and then begin the process of shopping around for the best brands and prices. Once you decide on the tire that fits your needs, make certain to check tire shops near you for inventory as well as online tire outlets for the best prices, as many of them will price match.
When the manufacturer decides on the original equipment tires (OEM) for each of the vehicles they make, they do so based on a mixture of cost, reliability, treadlife and capability. The tires that your car comes with, directly from the manufacturer, will be relatively good.
Depending on how long you have the vehicle, how much mileage you put on it, and the type of driver you are, replacing the OEM tires may be a good step. If you hit the trails on rainy winter nights, then you might want to opt for a more sturdy, off road or all terrain tire.
One criteria which should be considered when shopping for tires is the warranty offered by the manufacturer. A good tire will have a reasonable warranty which will cover a certain amount of time from the date of purchase, treadlife considerations and mileage estimates.
Warranty types include:
Learning how to read a tire can be a very helpful skill, specifically when shopping for the right tire for your vehicle. When shopping for tires, it’s important to understand what the numbers printed on the sidewall actually mean.
For example, this typical truck tire size 265/70R17 115T All-Season tires means the following:
You can download this helpful infographic here. If you reference the image on another platform, please provide a link back to this page.